Readers who have been in the cleared sector for some time may recall the name Aaron Alexis, AKA the Navy Yard shooter. Mr. Alexis, a cleared contractor and Navy reservist, killed twelve people and injured three others in a horrific case of targeted workplace violence in 2013.
Impetus for Safeguards
The incident was the impetus for additional workplace violence safeguards and a heightened focus on anger management issues and mental health across government, but especially in the personnel security sector. That’s not to suggest that security officials weren’t attuned to indicators of violence before the Navy Yard shooting, but the effects of the incident on adjudicator psychology were evident. Much like no one wanted to be the adjudicator who cleared the next Edward Snowden, no one wanted to be the adjudicator who cleared the next Aaron Alexis. After 2013, cases involving the potential for physical violence have, in my assessment, received more careful scrutiny.
There are plenty of examples of this in the published cases of the Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA). Still, one example I found particularly compelling is ISCR 21-01152, a case from 2022 in which the applicant, a 43-year-old veteran with self-diagnosed PTSD, demonstrated “a history and pattern of inappropriate, uncontrolled, emotional outbursts, getting upset, yelling, and swearing in front of his co-workers in the workplace.”
The workplace history is long and included multiple instances of screaming, profanities, and at least three statements suggesting or celebrating violence. In one instance, the applicant referenced being “eligible” to purchase a firearm. In another, he celebrated a building at work burning down. In another, he stated something to the effect of “You don’t know what I can do.” The final incident resulted in the convening of a workplace violence committee and the applicant being given a “last chance” agreement.
Some readers may be surprised that matters got that far before termination was contemplated. That’s a fair observation since the incidents at issue occurred well after the Navy Yard shooting when government (and government contractors, as in this case) were theoretically in a heightened state of awareness. I can only speculate, but my assumption is that the employer was wary of a disability discrimination lawsuit, particularly given the employee’s status as a veteran who was claiming PTSD. Either way, this case did eventually end with the employee being denied a security clearance after the Administrative Judge found that his “consistent pattern of behavior is indicative of an insider threat.”
Seeking Help
The record in this case is extreme, but it offers an important lesson for clearance-holders and applicants: the time to seek treatment for mental health challenges, including PTSD, is not when matters have escalated to the point of a workplace violence committee being convened and one’s employment being jeopardized. Rather, as we’ve often counseled at ClearanceJobs, most mental health conditions do not negatively impact one’s ability to obtain or retain a security clearance when treated early and appropriately.
As part of seeking qualified medical treatment instead of self-diagnosing for PTSD, this applicant would likely have benefited from anger management counseling. That was a tool I sometimes utilized in my law practice to great effect with clients facing similar challenges – not just in cases of PTSD, but also in divorce/child custody disputes and other life stressors that called into question the client’s mental stability and potential for violence. The pushback from some applicants was the same as the pushback for medical mental health treatment: “but it will jeopardize my clearance if the government finds out!” And, just like with mental health treatment, the truth is entirely the opposite.
Don’t believe me? Read Guidelines “E” and “I” of the National Adjudicative Guidelines for Security Clearances yourself here. Seeking professional help, whether counseling, medical treatment, or both, is a mitigating condition, not a basis for denying or revoking a security clearance. If you’re on the government’s radar as an insider threat and you haven’t sought professional help, you’ve likely missed the boat like the applicant in this DOHA case. Don’t let well-meaning friends, colleagues, or military commanders tell you otherwise.
This article is intended as general information only and should not be construed as legal advice. Although the information is believed to be accurate as of the publication date, no guarantee or warranty is offered or implied. Laws and government policies are subject to change, and the information provided herein may not provide a complete or current analysis of the topic or other pertinent considerations. Consult an attorney regarding your specific situation.



